Beyond the Main Idea: A Better Way to Teach Reading
Willy Renandya, 5 Feb 2025
When it comes to teaching reading, many educators default to a familiar strategy: helping students identify the main idea of a text. While this approach has been a cornerstone of reading instruction for decades, it often falls short of fostering true comprehension. Simply pinpointing key points or summarizing paragraphs doesn’t equip students with the tools they need to deeply engage with a text, analyze its meaning, or connect it to the world around them.
A recent Edutopia article sheds light on this issue, emphasizing the need to move beyond the “what” of a text—the surface-level details—and instead explore the “why” and “how.” This shift encourages students to think critically, ask questions, and make connections that go beyond rote memorization. But how can educators make this happen? The answer lies in tapping into students’ background knowledge and using it as a bridge to deeper understanding.
The Power of Background Knowledge
Background knowledge is the foundation of comprehension. When students can connect new information to what they already know, they’re better able to make sense of complex ideas, draw inferences, and retain what they’ve learned. For example, a student who has some understanding of the Civil Rights Movement will find it easier to grasp the themes of a novel like *To Kill a Mockingbird* than a student who lacks that context.
However, here’s the catch: activating background knowledge only works if students have that knowledge in the first place. Research shows that many students, particularly those from underserved communities, often lack the foundational knowledge needed to fully engage with grade-level texts. This creates a gap that traditional comprehension strategies, such as identifying the main idea or answering literal questions, simply can’t bridge.
The Role of Vocabulary in Building Knowledge
So, what’s the solution? One critical piece of the puzzle is vocabulary development. Why? Because background knowledge is often stored in our long-term memory as lexis , i.e., the words and phrases we use to represent concepts and ideas. The more words a student knows, the more connections they can make between new information and what they already understand.
For instance, a student who knows the meaning of words like “ecosystem,” “biodiversity,” and “sustainability” will have an easier time understanding a science article about climate change than a student who encounters these terms for the first time. Vocabulary isn’t just about memorizing definitions; it’s about building the mental framework needed to process and retain complex ideas.
Practical Strategies for Educators
To move beyond the limitations of traditional reading instruction, educators need to focus on two key areas: expanding students’ background knowledge and strengthening their vocabulary. Here are a few strategies to make this happen:
- Incorporate Real-Life Examples: Use real-world scenarios, case studies, and current events to make abstract concepts more concrete. For example, when teaching a historical text, connect it to modern-day issues that students can relate to.
- Leverage Visual Tools: Charts, diagrams, and graphic organizers can help students visualize relationships between ideas, making it easier to see the “bigger picture.”
- Facilitate Discussions: Encourage students to share their thoughts, ask questions, and debate ideas. Dialogue not only deepens understanding but also exposes students to different perspectives.
- Prioritize Vocabulary Instruction: Dedicate time to teaching high-utility words that appear across subjects, such as “analyze,” “evaluate,” and “interpret.” Use context-rich activities, like word maps or semantic webs, to help students internalize these terms.
- Build Knowledge Systematically: Choose texts and topics that build on one another, creating a coherent narrative over time. This helps students accumulate knowledge in a way that feels meaningful and interconnected.
Why This Approach Matters
The goal of reading instruction shouldn’t be to teach students how to extract information from a text—it should be to teach them how to think, learn, and engage with the world through reading. By focusing on background knowledge and vocabulary, educators can empower students to become confident, critical readers who are prepared to tackle complex texts and ideas.
In a world where information is constantly evolving, the ability to learn, adapt, and connect ideas is more important than ever. Moving beyond the main idea isn’t just a better way to teach reading—it’s a necessary step toward preparing students for the challenges and opportunities of the future.
So, let’s rethink how we approach reading instruction. Let’s move beyond the surface and dive into the depths of comprehension, where true learning begins.
Related readings